Sunday Reading for October 24, 2021

1. Anderson Pens Chicago: A Quick Walkthrough (via Pen Addict). Kimberly posts photos from her post-Chicago Pen Show trip to Anderson Pens. I’m returning to Chicago in a couple of weeks and certainly plan on stopping by Anderson Pens myself!

2. SCRIBO Piuma Utopia (via Dapprman). This review has me eager to test out the Piuma, the latest model from SCRIBO. While the design hasn’t tugged at my heartstrings, I recall that I wasn’t drawn to the Feel until I actually had that one in my hand.

3. Gravitas Entry Fountain Pen (via Pencilcase Blog). I still haven’t managed to review a Gravitas Pen. The finish on this “Entry” model is beautiful.

4. A Scary Project (via From the Pen Cup). A scary project, yes, but as Mary discusses in this post, there are quite practical reasons why you should have an inventory of your pen collection. I’m currently working on this myself.

5. Link Love: The Sad News Edition (via Well-Appointed Desk). I’ve written here and on social media about the sadness in learning that several stationery businesses I’ve loved and patronized over the years are closing shop. Ana rounds up exactly what’s been going on.

6. Dragon Bolt V: The Karas Pen Co. Bolt v2 with Dragonskin Grip (via Penquisition). There has been a bit of a mini-trend towards “dragon scale” or “dragon skin” patterns and textures on pens lately. This version from Karas looks interesting, and designed to enhance the grip on the pen.

7. Montblanc Notebooks: A Real Luxury Experience (via UK Fountain Pens). I have one of these in my “to review” pile, but have never pulled it out simply because I didn’t know whether there was much interest. They are quite beautiful and I’m glad to see the paper holds up.

8. Nock Co. Cases: An Urban Sketcher’s Companion (via Writing at Large). I do hope Brad continues to make limited runs of these cases, as the designs are great and quite versatile. While I don’t own multiples, I do have a Sinclair that is a key piece of my EDC.

9. Vinta Ulap: An Exclusive Worth Having (via UK Fountain Pens). Having just discovered Vinta inks myself, I can agree that they are exceptional. This shading grey looks amazing.

10. Ink Review #1643: Vinta Romblon (via Mountain of Ink). Here’s another plug for Vinta, this time in an interesting black with purple undertones. Subtle black inks are among my favorites.

In Case You Missed It…

This week I released two articles on topics I’ve been thinking on for a while. The first is an article about online pen shows, and how they’ve literally saved businesses during the pandemic, but at the same time hopefully won’t become the new normal. I also wrote a lighter piece on my fixation with black and matte-black pens, especially those with black trim, and why I think these are so enduringly popular. Finally, be sure to check out this post discussing some new features I’ve either launched or am in the process of launching.

So What’s New in the T.G.S. Curated Shop?

Planner Season continues on, as we all get geared up for year-end and start thinking about what we will/will not do differently in 2022. I’m still noodling on next year’s setup, but personally I’m loving my combined Traveler’s Notebook/modified Stálogy setup. We will continue to offer the full line of Traveler’s Notebook dated planners through the start of 2022, as well as other undated/flexible options such as the Stálogy Half-Year and 365-day planners and the Midori Day-to-a-Page Codex notebooks.

Traveler's Notebook

Stálogy

Pencils

Pens

Reading Accessories

Consider Joining TGS Patreon for Access to Monthly Meetups and First Dibs on Gently Used Stationery, Exclusive Products and More!

For some additional fun, and to help support the blog consider joining the Patreon program. Patreon supporters receive special pricing and early access to product releases and collaborations such as the T.G.S. x Sunderland pen, in addition to other benefits. You can read more about T.G.S. Patreon here. This year I’ve introduced monthly online meetups, which take place on Friday or Saturday and have been super enjoyable. The Patreon membership also has “first dibs” on my regular gently used stationery sales, and I’m currently working on a fresh batch of pens, inks, and notebooks that should hit the Patreon shop in the next couple of weeks.

The Allure of the Stealth Pen: What Makes the All-Black Pen So Popular?

For the first several years I participated seriously in this hobby (through the early-to-mid 2010s, it seemed as though pen companies were racing to introduce a “stealth” version of their various models, typically a black or matte black version of a pen featuring black-plated trim. (I’ve actually been around long enough to recall Pilot’s release of the current matte-black Vanishing Point, as well as a series of other VPs with matte-black trim and accents.) I’ve always wondered what makes these particular pens so popular. Black-on-black pens, and especially matte black pens, show no sign of going away anytime soon, so this week I spent some time noodling on it and felt compelled to put together an “all-black” carry for yesterday’s remote work outing.

View fullsize

From left, the Sailor 1911 “Black Luster” edition, my own T.G.S. x Sunderland mk1 rollerball, and the Montblanc “Midnight Black” Starwalker Rollerball. Case is a special edition Nock Co. Sinclair (since discontinued).

Originally, “stealth pen” marketing borrowed heavily from the “tactical pen” crowd, evoking military imagery, extreme durability, and touting the ability to bring your fountain pen along on those top-secret night missions. For example, I recall Monteverde marketing a pen with Goulet called the “Nighthawk” that featured black trim and a carbon fiber motif. Over the years, however, blacked-out pens and black trim in general became mainstream, not just a sub-category targeted to EDC (“everyday carry”) enthusiasts.

View fullsize

Contrary to popular belief, black pens don’t have to be boring. Not only can you add a splash of color to really set off the finish, but manufacturers can vary the design on things like the grip section to add a lot of character. Check out the knurling on the Montblanc Starwalker!

I’m not sure the popularity of black-on-black pens should come as a surprise. Black accessories of any sort are universally appreciated because they match easily, and while some might be hesitant to claim “black” as their favorite color, I’d venture that it has much wider appeal than the stereotypical “stealth pen” customer would suggest. Here are a few key reasons why I enjoy them myself:

• Sleek, Understated Look. In my “real” life as a working attorney, there are contexts in which I need a pen to blend in to the surroundings and not become a distraction. Court hearings, depositions, and crowded meetings are NOT the time to break out the bright red Pilot Custom Urushi, or the Krusac Scrimshaw Navigator. On the other hand, a black makrolon Lamy 2000, Lamy Studio LX All-Black, or Sailor Pro Gear Imperial Black doesn’t obviously turn heads at first glance (and most people won’t notice the Lamy 2000 isn’t a rollerball). In a culture where, unfortunately, many consider using any sort of decent pen or pencil to be a pretentious affectation, black pens can be a good choice where you feel as though you need to fly under the radar.

• Better Grip and Texture. My favorite pens are what I call my “workhorses,” or pens that I can write with all day. Matte-finish pens offer a pleasant grip and texture for all-day writing sessions or when you’re in a hot room with sweaty hands. The pen won’t get slick.

• Black Pens Age Well. As I’ll further discuss below, most black pens, and especially matte black pens, will eventually show some wear and tear. Personally, I find that it adds to the aesthetic and I will never replace a pen for this reason. Look no further than my Sailor Pro Gear Imperial Black, which not only has worn smooth and shiny on the barrel from years of regular use, but now has a partially chrome (as opposed to black-plated) cap finial. I have experienced zero wear, however, on the black ion plating to the nib, clip, or cap band.

View fullsize

Some flaking on the cap finial is actually the only real wear and tear on my eight-year-old Sailor Imperial Black Fountain pen, which I re-reviewed years after I first purchased the pen.

Eight years and one dropped nib repair later, the nib on my Sailor Imperial Black looks just as good as it did when I first purchased this pen! Thanks Mark!

Of course, there are also some considerations that anyone considering a matte black pen - especially one with black trim - should keep in mind. First, if you’re particular about scratches, chipping, and visible wear on your pens, this finish may not be for you. Most matte texture is created using some form of powder-coating or anodization, and no matter how careful you are with your pens, the finish will eventually wear smooth, and you will likely accumulate some dings and scratches. As I noted above, I love how this looks over time, and merely serves as a reminder that my pens are tools meant to be used, but hey, personal preference. Second, if you are considering a pen with a plated or coated nib, talk to an experienced nib grinder before performing any sort of modification on the pen. Different manufacturers use different techniques to plate their nibs, and depending on the quality of the work and materials used, the coating can start to peel or flake off if the nib is ground. That’s not to say you can’t do it, but I’ve experienced it on a few pens across multiple brands and price points. (You can’t blame the manufacturers for this. When you choose to grind a nib, you are, after all, modifying their pen in a way that they did not originally intend. You are responsible for educating yourself on all the different things that might occur as a result.)

View fullsize

You know that you’ve really gone off the deep end when you find yourself purchasing things like these matte black Allex scissors, not necessarily because you have a burning use case for them, but because C.W. Pencil Enterprise is closing and, well, you just need these for your desk. (Great scissors, btw.)

While there have been murmurs in the pen blogosphere about blacked-out pens being “tired” or “played out,” I expect them to continue to sell well, and for manufacturers to continue to make these pens for as long as demand holds up. Personally, I consider this a classic design, and would love to see black trim in particular become a default option alongside the black/gold and black/rhodium that you see everywhere. I can’t help but think it might even outperform the current “standards.” Consider some other possibilities. I mean, Lamy recently released a brown Lamy 2000 with a brown plated clip. If they released a version of the 2000 with a ruthenium-plated clip, section, and nib, can you imagine how well that would sell?

(Maybe terribly, but I don’t care. I still want it.)

View fullsize

You can’t accuse me of inconsistency. I’ve always loved a matte-black pen with a dark red section. Here, the visibility isn’t the best because the alumilite has darkened over the years, but my Newton Shinobi is black ebonite with a dark, blood red alumilite section.

Ending with a Shameless Plug for the T.G.S. x Sunderland Machine Works MK1

Since I love black pens, it’s not a coincidence that I chose to incorporate a matte black finish into the first exclusive pen collaboration that I’ve done: the T.G.S. x Sunderland Machine Works mk1 matte-black and burgundy release. While you can read more on the specs for this pen in the shop listing, this release pairs the comfortable and functional Sunderland mk1 design with a durable bead-blasted matte-black and burgundy finish, along with a DLC (Diamond-Like-Coating) black stainless steel clip. I need to give Sunderland mad props for the durability of the finish on this pen - as I noted above, most matte pens will show wear over time, especially if you toss it into bags, pen cases, and pockets. After more than seven months of hard use, however, my current demo shows no wear, which can only be a testament to the quality of the processes used. (Note: I’ve intentionally NOT been gentle with this pen, since I wanted to see how it would hold up in the real world.)

View fullsize

Yes - the section threads are internal, so they don’t interfere with your grip.

I’d love to do more pen collaborations in the future, and given how well this one has sold, you can expect more from me in the coming year. The T.G.S. x Sunderland pen is not a limited edition, but it is a store exclusive, so you can only get it directly from the T.G.S. Curated Shop. Priced at $110, it’s a slight premium over the standard Sunderland mk1, mainly due to the cost of the bead-blasted finish and DLC coating. All proceeds go to support and grow T.G.S., both the blog and the fledgling shop operation!

View fullsize

This post does not contain paid third-party affiliate links. By shopping with us directly, you are supporting original content, pen reviews, pen show events, etc. from The Gentleman Stationer. If you would like to support us even further, please consider checking out the T.G.S. Patreon Program, which offers access to online meetups, exclusive discounts (including a slight price break on the Sunderland) pre-orders, and more!

Deals & Drops: PEEK-a-Boo! New Release from Schon DSGN, Favorite Stealth Pens, and More!

While we will have one more set of links and a week’s worth of posts before both Halloween and Fountain Pen Day 2021, I couldn’t resist headlining this week’s edition of Deals and Drops with the release of the Schon DSGN “Peek” fountain pen, Ian’s latest creation that uses the ultra-lightweight plastic peek. In the spirit of the upcoming holiday, I thought I’d also feature a few of my favorite matte-black pens, including our exclusive collaboration with Sunderland Machine Works, and the Caran d’Ache “Black Code” 849. Finally, there’s a new Inktober-themed ink from Joey Feldman and Vanness Pens, and this one’s an orange!

I’ll also go ahead and link to last week’s Deals & Drops post, which focused on planners and planner pens, since it will be “planner season” through the end of the year.

Happy Shopping!

This post does not contain paid third-party affiliate links, and unless otherwise noted, all links are to the T.G.S. Curated Shop, an authorized retailer of all brands we carry. By shopping with us directly, you are supporting original content, pen reviews, pen show events, etc. from The Gentleman Stationer. If you would like to support us even further, please consider checking out the T.G.S. Patreon Program, which offers access to online meetups, exclusive discounts and pre-orders, and more!

1. Schon DSGN “Engineered Plastics” Fountain Pens (via SchonDSGN). Ian recently released his “Peek” fountain pen, with a Halloween-themed surprise engraved on the cap. Don’t forget to check out the “Ultem” pens as well, which are also made from uitra-lightweight engineered plastic.

2. T.G.S. x Sunderland mk1 Rollerball. This year we launched our first T.G.S. pen collaboration, a Sunderland mk1 rollerball featuring a stealthy bead-blasted matte black anodized finish, a matte burgundy section, and a DLC-coated stainless steel clip (also with matching bead-blasted finish) for maximum durability. Just a handful left in stock leading up to the holidays!

3. Caran d’Ache 849 “Black Code” Edition. We’re fully restocked on Caran d’Ache’s all-matte-black version of the classic 849 ballpoint (which includes a matching clip and knock). And if matte black isn’t your thing, we carry the full range of 849 pens and pencils.

4. Esterbrook Estie Nouveau Blue (via Vanness Pens). The latest Esterbrook Estie is an art nouveau-inspired beauty, featuring vintage-style material reminiscent of early celluloid pens. I’m still trying to decide between silver or gold trim.

5. Joey Feldman “October Drawing Challenge” 2021 Limited Edition Ink (via Vanness Pens). Vanness and Joey Feldman collaborate annually on an limited edition ink for the “Inktober” drawing challenge, and this year they chose an orange!

6. Platinum Preppy Wa Limited Edition Fountain Pens. This year Platinum launched this limited run of Preppy fountain pens inspired by traditional Japanese culture. There are six different designs, and you can have them all for less than $50? Preppies are also easily eyedroppered with a bit of silicon grease or an o-ring, and these bright designs make them perfect for color-matching with your favorite ink.

7. Traveler’s Notebook 2022 Diary Refills. Now is the perfect time to purchase your 2022 planner for your Traveler’s Notebook or other Traveler’s-size planner. We have dated refills in a variety of monthly and weekly layouts.

8. Midori MD Diary Stickers. Do you ever wish you could turn your everyday notebook into a planner without having to draw in a calendar yourself? These Midori MD Diary Stickers, available in two different sizes, let you do just that. Stickers are made from Midori MD Paper so they work great with all sorts of ink.

9. Traveler’s Notebook B-Sides and Rarities. This year Traveler’s Company released a new set of refills into their standard lineup, dubbed the “B-Sides & Rarities” collection, which features unique papers and accessories such as the popular Cotton Zipper Cases and an MD Cotton Letter Pad (a notebook that can be used in or out of a Traveler’s Notebook).

10. New Arrivals from Kokuyo. The T.G.S. Curated Shop is stocked with all sorts of new arrivals from Japanese stationery Kokuyo, including the textured, fountain pen friendly PERPANEP paper, as well as new colors of the hardback “Sketch Book” and “Trip Book” pocket notebooks.

View fullsize

Midori MD Diary Stickers (Dated and Undated) allow you to turn any notebook into a planner, using these stickers made from MD Paper. Available in two sizes.

View fullsize

We still have Platinum Preppy Wa fountain pens in stock! What’s your favorite?

Online Pen Shows: They May Be Easier, But Are They Really The Same?

Before we get started, I want to make clear that in this post I’m not criticizing any single brand, company or online pen show, even if they happen to be mentioned by name in this article. Any such discussion is solely for illustrative purposes since I suspect what I talk about here is going to be an emerging industry-wide trend that is here to stay and that everyone is going to have to live with in some way or another.

When literally all of the post-Baltimore pen shows were cancelled in 2020, both sellers and enthusiasts were faced with the prospect of having a primary revenue stream completely shut down, an existential threat for many. As a way to adapt, many retailers and makers turned to “online pen shows” - essentially, windows in which exclusive, limited, or discounted products were made available for purchase online. The way in which an online pen show works varies. For example, Franklin-Christoph announces ahead of time that certain models will be made available in their Stock Room, similar to how C.W. Pencil Enterprise released their Pencil Advent Calendar. Others attempted to duplicate an actual in-person pen show experience. Ian Schon offered time slots for customers to peruse pens via Zoom, and the St. Louis Pen Show went virtual, offering courses and content via YouTube. But while I’m thankful that these options were available to help keep the pen industry and associated community viable throughout the pandemic, I hope they don’t replace traditional shows and opportunities for in-person shopping over the long-haul, as some are suggesting they should. Here are my thoughts on both the advantages and disadvantages of these types of shows.

Benefits of Online Pen Shows

• Safety. This one goes without saying. Depending on COVID-19 levels at any given time in any given area, it may not be safe to attend in-person events. Online options are a viable alternative should an event or retailer need to cancel.

• Increased Accessibility. Even setting aside the pandemic, one key benefit to these sorts of online events is increased accessibility to those who can’t make it to an in-person pen show due to health, distance, etc. The beauty of the internet (for the most part) stems from its ability to bring otherwise geographically distant people together.

• Small-Business Friendly. Extremely small makers, or those just starting out, may not have the resources to travel to shows or to stock any sort of in-person store. The ability to operate online levels the playing field to a certain degree, not only in terms of accessibility but in allowing smaller retailers with higher costs to compete on price.

I likely would never have purchased many of the pens in my current collection (including these Franklin-Christoph Model 20s) without the opportunity to see the material and handle each pen in person.

Drawbacks to the Online-Only Model

• Amazonification of the Experience. Part of what I love about visiting pen shows (as well as brick-and-mortar pen stores) is the ability to not only view products in person before I make a purchase, but to interact and engage with the makers and retailers themselves. If you take away this aspect of the experience, to me it becomes much less attractive. Buying a pen online, especially a handmade or secondhand pen, sight unseen, doesn’t hold the same cachet, especially since I often want to experience in-person a pen that I plan to use for writing over the long-haul.

• Loss of Community. The friendships I’ve made through pen shows are priceless. Whether it’s gathering around a table discussing a new release or prototype design, having a friend let me write with a pen from their collection so I can decide whether it works for me, or simply meeting like-minded people who you keep in touch with outside of shows, the ability to socialize with others is a key part of what makes in-person pen shows irreplaceable, IMHO.

• Consumer Frustration. When dealing with limited run or limited release products, it can be extremely frustrating for fans and enthusiasts to take time out of their workday or schedule to be online at the time of a “drop,” only to have the product sell out in less than 2 minutes (i.e., before most people can add the product to their cart and pay). However unfair it may be to the retailer or maker, who often has no control over the quantities available and/or techniques buyers use to jump to the head of the queue (see third bullet below), it creates resentment at what the shopper perceives as wasted time. Many people, myself included, don’t enjoy a “gamified” experience where part of the thrill is not knowing whether you will “get one” or not, or knowing that I will have to quickly drop $500 (or sometimes more) unless I’m willing to risk never being able to buy one of these products again.

• Benefiting Profiteers and Resellers. Adding to customer resentment over their inability to have a fair shot at getting a limited run pen or other special release is the fact that many of these products immediately appear on third-party retailer websites, often marked up 2x or 3x. This isn’t a new trend by any means, as it’s plagued other industries for years, but it may become more prevalent in the pen community if people move to an online-only model. Japan has recently seen a proliferation of companies whose business consists entirely of buying up store exclusives and other limited releases solely for the purpose of reselling, primarily to overseas buyers.

Takeaways and Final Thoughts

Look, there’s no avoiding the fact that the past two years have been a giant unknown filled with uncertainty for pretty much everyone involved in our industry and community (most of all the makers and retailers), and everyone has had to get creative just to keep the lights on. That said, I personally am of the opinion that every effort needs to be made to preserve traditional retail and show options, or else we lose not just the social aspect of this community in general but the accessibility of products to all but the most tech-saavy or those willing to pay reseller mark-ups. While I understand that online shows and product drops are beneficial to retailers from a revenue perspective (i.e., you sell a lot of pens without incurring the costs of traveling to shows, working through distributors, etc.), I can also see how this runs the risk of frustrating/alienating a large portion of the market, and encouraging things like hoarding/FOMO buying/profiteering. There is a segment of the pen community with a strong focus on accumulation and “buying all the things,” regardless of intent to actually use the product, and while people are free to spend their money however they want, certain retail and marketing strategies cater more to this group than others.

This post does not contain affiliate links. I purchased the pens, nibs, and nib units featured in this post with my own funds, for my own collection. The Gentleman Stationer is reader-supported. If you would like to support us, please consider purchasing from the T.G.S. Curated Shop or checking out the T.G.S. Patreon Program, which offers access to online meetups, exclusive discounts and pre-orders, and more!

Tuesday Update: Revamped Archive, Updated Resources, and A New E-mail Option

I’ve fallen behind on housekeeping lately, and it was actually fairly satisfying to use part of last week’s “Staycation” to finish up some necessary behind-the-scenes updates to the blog archive and informational resources. There’s a wealth of content here at T.G.S. and one of my ongoing projects has been to figure out how best to make the back archive more easily navigable. Recently, I’ve added a new feature: a Pen Review archive that organizes all of the past T.G.S. Reviews, by brand, as well as an updated “Workhorse Pens” page that contains links to all of the posts I’ve written on pens I consider to be true “workhorses,” just like the Opus 88s I reviewed on Saturday. For those curious about my evaluation process, I try to update all of my various “Best Pen Recommendations” at least annually, and sometimes more frequently, as I do with my running post on Fountain Pen Friendly Paper. I hope you find these useful in making informed decisions on the pens, inks, and paper that you’re looking to purchase and use!

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by The Gentleman Stationer (@gentlemanstationer)

Finally, if you follow me on social media, and if you read this week’s Sunday Reading, you’ll know about the ever-increasing difficulties facing small businesses these days. It’s even harder where the majority of your online activity is devoted to providing free content, and I’d like to keep it that way. If you’re a longtime reader, and want to help support T.G.S., please consider joining the T.G.S. Patreon Program to offer your monthly support (there’s also a discounted annual pledge option), and if you’re in the market for a new pen, ink, or notebook, please consider shopping our curated selection of goods in the T.G.S. Curated Shop. Under the advice of friends much more experienced in online retail than I am, I also plan to launch a monthly “shop update” e-mail that is currently in the works, and which I plan to be less-frequent-but-more-involved than the typical e-mail blasts you receive from retailers, meaning more detail on why I’ve chosen to stock certain products and how I think they fit the vision of my shop. If you’d like to sign up to receive this e-mail, just visit the “subscribe” e-mail on the side bar and opt-in to receive e-mail marketing notices. (There’s also an opportunity to opt-in when you check out in the shop.)

Again, many thanks for all of you who have supported T.G.S. over the years, and I’m doing everything I can to make sure T.G.S. stays around for the long haul!